Multiprocessing vs Multithreading in python

Stanislav Lazarenko
9 min readFeb 27, 2023

--

Multiprocessing and multithreading are two techniques used to achieve parallelism in software applications.

  • Multiprocessing: Multiprocessing involves using multiple processes to execute tasks concurrently. Each process has its own memory space and runs independently of other processes, communicating with them through inter-process communication (IPC). Multiprocessing is well-suited for CPU-bound tasks, where the main bottleneck is CPU usage, as it allows multiple CPUs or cores to be used to execute tasks in parallel.
  • Multithreading: Multithreading involves using multiple threads within a single process to execute tasks concurrently. All threads share the same memory space and can access the same data and resources, but run independently of each other. Multithreading is well-suited for I/O-bound tasks, where the main bottleneck is input/output operations, as it allows the application to continue executing other tasks while waiting for I/O operations to complete.

Here are some key differences between multiprocessing and multithreading:

  • CPU usage: Multiprocessing is better suited for CPU-bound tasks, as it allows multiple processes to use multiple CPUs or cores in parallel. Multithreading is better suited for I/O-bound tasks, where the main bottleneck is input/output operations.
  • Memory usage: Multiprocessing requires more memory than multithreading, as each process has its own memory space. Multithreading uses less memory, as all threads share the same memory space.
  • Inter-process communication: Multiprocessing requires inter-process communication (IPC) to communicate between processes, which can be slower and more complex than inter-thread communication. Multithreading uses inter-thread communication, which is faster and simpler than IPC.
  • Debugging: Debugging multiprocessing applications can be more complex than debugging multithreading applications, as each process runs independently and has its own memory space. Debugging multithreading applications can be simpler, as all threads share the same memory space.

In general, the choice of multiprocessing or multithreading depends on the specific requirements and constraints of the application. Applications that require high CPU usage may benefit from multiprocessing, while applications that require high I/O usage may benefit from multithreading. It is important to consider factors such as CPU usage, memory usage, inter-process communication, and debugging when choosing a parallelism strategy.

Multiprocessing vs Multithreading in python

In Python, multiprocessing and multithreading are both used to achieve parallelism in software applications.

  1. Multiprocessing in Python: The multiprocessing module in Python allows multiple processes to be used to execute tasks concurrently. Each process has its own memory space and runs independently of other processes, communicating with them through inter-process communication (IPC). The multiprocessing module provides a simple interface for spawning new processes, communicating between processes, and synchronizing access to shared resources.
  2. Multithreading in Python: The threading module in Python allows multiple threads within a single process to execute tasks concurrently. All threads share the same memory space and can access the same data and resources, but run independently of each other. The threading module provides a simple interface for creating new threads, communicating between threads, and synchronizing access to shared resources.

Here are some key differences between multiprocessing and multithreading in Python:

  • GIL: In Python, the Global Interpreter Lock (GIL) limits the ability of multithreading to take advantage of multiple CPUs or cores. The GIL restricts the execution of Python code to a single thread at a time, making it difficult to achieve true parallelism using multithreading. Multiprocessing does not have this limitation, as each process has its own GIL and can execute Python code in parallel.
  • Memory usage: Multiprocessing requires more memory than multithreading, as each process has its own memory space. Multithreading uses less memory, as all threads share the same memory space.
  • Inter-process communication: Multiprocessing in Python requires inter-process communication (IPC) to communicate between processes, which can be slower and more complex than inter-thread communication. Multithreading in Python uses inter-thread communication, which is faster and simpler than IPC.
  • Debugging: Debugging multiprocessing applications in Python can be more complex than debugging multithreading applications, as each process runs independently and has its own memory space. Debugging multithreading applications in Python can be simpler, as all threads share the same memory space.

In general, the choice of multiprocessing or multithreading in Python depends on the specific requirements and constraints of the application. Applications that require high CPU usage may benefit from multiprocessing, while applications that require high I/O usage may benefit from multithreading. It is important to consider factors such as CPU usage, memory usage, inter-process communication, and debugging when choosing a parallelism strategy in Python.

How GIL works?

The Global Interpreter Lock (GIL) is a mechanism used in CPython, the default implementation of the Python programming language, to ensure that only one thread can execute Python bytecode at a time. The purpose of the GIL is to protect access to Python objects and prevent concurrent access to shared data structures from corrupting the memory.

Here’s how the GIL works:

  1. The GIL is a lock that is acquired and released by the Python interpreter for each thread in the process.
  2. When a thread wants to execute Python code, it must first acquire the GIL. If the GIL is already held by another thread, the requesting thread will be blocked until the lock is released.
  3. Once the thread acquires the GIL, it can execute Python code in the interpreter until it releases the lock.
  4. When the thread is done executing Python code, it releases the GIL so that other threads can acquire the lock and execute their own code.

Because only one thread can acquire the GIL at a time, the GIL can limit the parallelism of Python code that is CPU-bound. This is because even if multiple threads are created, only one thread can execute Python code at a time. However, the GIL has little to no impact on Python code that is I/O-bound or that spends most of its time waiting for external resources, since the GIL is released while waiting for I/O.

It’s important to note that the GIL only affects CPython, the default implementation of Python. Other implementations of Python, such as Jython or IronPython, do not have a GIL and can take advantage of multiple cores or CPUs. Additionally, Python provides multiprocessing and threading modules that allow developers to use multiple processes or threads to execute Python code in parallel, even with the GIL limitation.

Limitations of Python in multithreading

Python’s multithreading module has some limitations due to the Global Interpreter Lock (GIL), which is a mechanism used by the CPython interpreter to ensure that only one thread can execute Python bytecode at a time. Here are some limitations of Python’s multithreading module:

  1. Limited parallelism: Because of the GIL, only one thread can execute Python bytecode at a time, which limits the amount of parallelism that can be achieved using multithreading in Python. This can be a problem for CPU-bound tasks that require significant amounts of processing time.
  2. CPU-bound tasks: Python’s multithreading module is less effective for CPU-bound tasks because of the GIL. In cases where the task is primarily CPU-bound, it may be better to use multiprocessing instead of multithreading.
  3. Interpreted language: Python is an interpreted language, which means that the interpreter must be running in order to execute Python code. This can make it more difficult to take full advantage of multiple cores or CPUs.
  4. Lock contention: Because multiple threads are sharing the same memory space, there can be issues with lock contention, where multiple threads are trying to access the same resources simultaneously. This can lead to performance issues and even deadlocks.
  5. Thread synchronization: Managing thread synchronization in Python can be more complex than in other languages, as there are many different synchronization primitives available, such as locks, semaphores, and conditions.

In general, the limitations of Python’s multithreading module are related to the GIL and the limitations of an interpreted language. However, there are still many use cases where Python’s multithreading module can be effective, such as for I/O-bound tasks or for managing concurrent access to shared resources.

Additionally, Python provides other parallelism modules, such as the multiprocessing module, that can be used to overcome some of these limitations.

Deadlock in scope of multithreading

A deadlock in multithreading occurs when two or more threads are blocked, waiting for each other to release a resource that they need in order to proceed. Deadlocks can occur in multithreading when there are multiple threads sharing resources such as locks, semaphores, or shared data structures.

Here is an example of a deadlock in multithreading:

Thread 1 acquires lock A and then attempts to acquire lock B.

Thread 2 acquires lock B and then attempts to acquire lock A.

Both threads are now waiting for the other to release a lock that they need in order to proceed. This can result in a deadlock, where both threads are blocked indefinitely and the application is no longer responsive.

Deadlocks in multithreading can be difficult to detect and resolve, as they often depend on the timing and ordering of thread execution. To avoid deadlocks in multithreading, it is important to follow good coding practices and to be careful when sharing resources between threads. Some tips to avoid deadlocks in multithreading include:

  1. Use a lock hierarchy: Make sure that threads always acquire locks in the same order to avoid deadlocks.
  2. Use timeouts: Use timeouts when acquiring locks to ensure that threads do not block indefinitely.
  3. Use atomic operations: Use atomic operations when possible to avoid the need for locks and reduce the risk of deadlocks.
  4. Use thread-safe data structures: Use thread-safe data structures and avoid sharing data structures between threads whenever possible.
  5. Test and debug: Test and debug multithreaded code carefully, using techniques such as logging and debugging tools to identify and resolve deadlocks.

By following these tips and being careful when sharing resources between threads, it is possible to avoid deadlocks in multithreading and ensure that your application remains responsive and reliable.

Communication between Python processes

In a multiprocessing environment, it is often necessary for processes to communicate with each other in order to share information, coordinate activities, or synchronize their work. There are several ways to implement inter-process communication (IPC) in Python, including:

  1. Pipes: Pipes are a simple way to communicate between two processes. In Python, pipes can be created using the multiprocessing.Pipe() function. One end of the pipe is used to send data, while the other end is used to receive data. Pipes are typically used for small amounts of data and are most effective for communication between two processes.
  2. Queues: Queues are similar to pipes, but can be used to communicate between more than two processes. In Python, queues can be created using the multiprocessing.Queue() function. Queues allow processes to send and receive data in a first-in, first-out (FIFO) order, and can be used to transfer larger amounts of data between processes.
  3. Shared memory: Shared memory is a technique that allows multiple processes to access the same block of memory. In Python, shared memory can be implemented using the multiprocessing.Value() and multiprocessing.Array() functions. Shared memory is typically used for large amounts of data that need to be shared between multiple processes.
  4. Sockets: Sockets can be used to communicate between processes running on different machines or on the same machine. In Python, sockets can be implemented using the socket module. Sockets can be used for communication between any number of processes, but are typically slower and more complex than other forms of IPC.

In general, the choice of IPC mechanism in Python depends on the specific requirements and constraints of the application. Pipes and queues are simple and effective for communication between a small number of processes, while shared memory can be more efficient for larger amounts of data. Sockets can be used for communication between any number of processes, but are typically slower and more complex than other forms of IPC. It is important to consider factors such as the amount of data to be transferred, the number of processes involved, and the complexity of the communication when choosing an IPC mechanism.

How Python manages memory (Garbage Collector/Refcount)

Python manages memory using two primary mechanisms: reference counting and garbage collection.

  1. Reference counting: Python uses reference counting to keep track of how many references exist to an object. Every time an object is created or assigned to a variable, the reference count for that object is incremented. When a reference to an object is deleted or goes out of scope, the reference count is decremented. When the reference count for an object reaches zero, the object is deleted from memory.
  2. Garbage collection: In addition to reference counting, Python uses a garbage collector to clean up objects that are no longer referenced. The garbage collector is responsible for detecting objects that have circular references, or objects that are not reachable from the main program, and deleting them from memory.

Python’s garbage collector runs automatically in the background and uses a mark-and-sweep algorithm to detect and clean up unused objects. The mark-and-sweep algorithm works by first marking all objects that are still in use, and then sweeping through memory to delete objects that are not marked. The garbage collector can be configured using the gc module, which provides functions for controlling the threshold for when garbage collection occurs and for manually running the garbage collector.

In general, Python’s memory management is designed to be simple and automatic, allowing developers to focus on writing code rather than managing memory manually. However, it is still important to be aware of memory usage and to avoid creating unnecessary objects or circular references that can lead to memory leaks.

Sign up to discover human stories that deepen your understanding of the world.

Free

Distraction-free reading. No ads.

Organize your knowledge with lists and highlights.

Tell your story. Find your audience.

Membership

Read member-only stories

Support writers you read most

Earn money for your writing

Listen to audio narrations

Read offline with the Medium app

--

--

Responses (1)

Write a response